Do you have account with Discount Broker? or Full Time Broker?
Poll has expired, here are the final results

Oct 1st Sharemarket No more "Zero Brokerage" and "Discount Brokers"? What to do?

47°
Deal Lieutenant
DEEPANGEORGE

Hello Dimers,

You all probably will know that recently SEBI CIRCULAR SEBI/HO/MRD/TPD-1/P/CIR/2024/92 , mentioned that there can't be zero brokerage kind of thing anymore from Oct 1st 2024


So whats your take on this dimers?

Refer an article to understand: 

1) How SEBI's New Circular Will Impact Zero Brokerage Services: What Traders Need to Know (marketcalls.in)

2) Explained: Sebi order on MII charges; Impact on stock brokers, investors | News on Markets - Business Standard (business-standard.com)


So whats your view on this Discount brokers fate????

Please share your views in comments below, eager to hear the different views smile and how sharemarket COMMISSION WILL EVOLVE ALONG WITH INCREASED TAXATION smile



Do we need to PAY the long forgotten charge called BROKERAGE ??

Please comment dont forget xDDD do share which broker you use in comments below

7 Comments  |  
3 Dimers
  • Sort By
Deal Newbie Deal Newbie
Link Copied
As much as 90% of the revenue of Zeroadha alone is/was coming from rebates in brokerage (that) it gives/gave on F and O trades.

Allowing naked positions has been one of THE worst form of giving 'the short end of the stick'.. to the retail investors.
It is especially a much bigger concern for markets that lack enough depth and are easier to manipulate given the lack of maturity within the system.

However this is not a sermon, nor I intend to preach.
Mr. Kamath (of Zeroadha) already hinted that the F and O customers might get impacted more, whereas the delivery based equity trades would see some nominal brokerages to begin with.

Since I never used and hopefully never will use all these Groww, Upstox, AngelOne, Zeroadha type entities, nor consult much with those who are their customers
I may not know of the finer details of being a customer of discount brokerages.

I do however know that the authorities and powers that be.. are in consultations with the stakeholders (including these discount brokerages) to further understand and work out an overall better fit for everyone.

In the short run though, yes, retail investors and short term traders too would need to incorporate these nominal costs by way of charges on delivery trades too.

Thankfully, the impact on F and O traderers would be significantly higher than on direct equity investors.

If it were up to me to influence such decisions,
Indian markets would have been a much stable and much more safe place for retail investors
if all derivatives trades were only and only covered trades (no short selling allowed without actually holding the underlying).
Derivatives were meant to be a hedge against a price risk at a future time.
Unfortunately it was reduced to gambling, market manipulation and defrauding the investors by launching complex (layered) products based on such derivatives.
Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied

mhm well have to wait and see on the fate of discount broker and their zero brokerage delivery trades


personally i am fan of zero delivery brokerage and I have accounts with most of the full time brokers with brokerage as well as discount brokers you mentioned with zero delivery charge (Groww, Upstox, Zeroadha) and AngelOne is full time broker not discount broker (sadly i dont have account with Angelone because of their maintenance charge yearly in a tricky name)


Now i dont know what they are gonna charge in their brokerage hence worried on how much all the brokers are gonna increase their charges in brokerage


Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied

hmmm anyone in share market, not worried about brokerage anymore? just wondering

Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied
@timesnewroman hehe true

well from the moment i got in stock market i always checked all charges xD hehehe sadly not many are into accounts and things i guess
View 2 more replies
Deal Lieutenant Deal Lieutenant
Link Copied

AS I THOUGH EVERYONE  STARTED CHARGING LOOL

image

replyuser
Click here to reply
Reply