Rethink design of SC and ST reservations/No 100% quota: On overzealous reservation

Exactly. Govt should put income limit on every where. Let get benefits to everyone.

Fully agree

There must be Income based Reservation rather than Caste based Reservation

Doesn’t matter where there is a income threshold or not. Both options are evil.

Evil is Evil. Lesser, greater, middling… Makes no difference. The degree is arbitary. The definition’s blurred. If I’m to choose between one evil and another… I’d rather not choose at all.

if any of the family member are in govt job (with his/her own efforts or with the help of reservation) then his son or daughter as the Case me be they shouldnt be allowed to take benefit or reservation or its can be completEly finished

I would change my idea about the government if they implement this, all their sins would be forgotten

Reservation is for representation. bc makes up 60% of the total population but the same percentage doesn’t reflect in gov positions.
The discrimination is done based on caste how could the affirmative action be based on anything else.

I think to help financial challenged persons there are other various gov welfare schemes

Aaj k time m reservation hi to india ko aage bhdne se rok rha h….reservation hi hta dena chahiye

Reservation should only be based on economic need or else it should be completely removed. Present system has long passed its expiry date. Still remember how many people especially women and children were attacked during Jat reservation stir. No one, absolutely no one can claim to have a “right” to reservation.

This is something our govt should focus on

people must see MAHABHARATA . where Karna/Eklavya were debarred for sake of Arjuna….history/mythology is full of discreminbation…

human made other human untouchable…. now nature made every 1 on earth untouchable..

How to expiry date

@guest_999

I just ask for 1 thing. “Change in current system of reservation after detailed assessment.”
The present system was introduced by Dr Bhimrao Ambedkar for 10 years for bringing social juetice.

If we still need it after 70 years for same reason and in same format then it simply means that the current format is inadequate to address the cause.

Bring on the assessment, discussion and reasearch on topic, maybe we needs more reservation to bring social justice or maybe we need to remove some sections from it.

Whatever it may be but I don’t think we need more than 10 years to address the root cause if we work carefully on it.
So why not take this as a challenge and work with full capacity for next 10 years continuesly revamping the measures and end social justice (if present in society) and thus the reservation.

*

Modi stop reservation

…There shouldn’t be any reservation….

…brahmans alone should not be priests in temple….atleast half of the temples should have priests from other castes….

…Caste remarks should be minimum 10 year punishable….

….Honour killing should be non bailable and punishment should be death…

….Govt should make sure that money and property should be divided appropriately among all castes…

Well i belong to SC category middle class family. Heard about discrimination but not experienced it untill the day came, during my engineering days i decided to leave hostel and move to room in city as other friends. While searching room i found owners asking for caste and category and after knowing they say, " No rooms for backward class". After not being able to find a room i have to get adjusted in my friends room. (Friends are of upper category as per the category ranks we see). Now when i got job in one of reputed govt. institute on basic of talent from unreserved category. Problem still exist to get a house. In workplace all is well Untill they came to know about category there behaviour changes. Even the lowest position person e.g. peon won’t behave good. So if a person like me whose family is well educated facing this kind of situation then the situation for others will be much more difficult.
Also seen many proposals which are good gets rejected by bosses due to person belong to lower category and accepted dubious persons proposals due to there caste. Which as excepted fails. While some bosses say we need to help uplifting the lower class of society and search for person deserving and guide them accordingly and get there proposal cleared and help them establish some business.
It is not 1 caste/category vs other. As many from other category knows and understand problem and helps. It is just a mind set of some which needs to be address first.

…This caste system…this religious discrimination…this is all a filthy stinking gutter…..
…5 years back In delhi we are like we had forgotten religion from discriminatory point of view…but it all changed….Somebody vitiated the atmosphere….
…Now sikhs are again being looked like sikhs…sic!
…Muslims…They are the 5th Varna now..
….Y cant we be Indians only?…

the apex court cant be 100% correct in all cases. they can be biased too. media conference by apex court judges in past is proof . president (actually ruling party)nominated ex cji to RS. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/polit.... v are leaving in society where 3000 cr can b spent on a statue but not hospitals/education. Drs from that state knows better….let this corona time gets over. every 1 will b busy again doing mandeer/statue again instead of necessities like medical,education etc ….cant our Judges study some good social engineering model country like SA/USA. In these countries, leaders from deprived society leaders rose to most powerful position(president) in those countries ; eg. Mandela / Lincoln .. in our society person from these class cant b MP (coz gen/obc wont vote for them ,even if they are better candidate than others) from a general LS seat ; leave the post of PM. these are truth and bitter reality of our society in india…

…If you say anyone can change his caste anytime..I pity your knowledge…

One should thing in this way,
a incompetent techer can affect life of how many students in his/her life?
a incompetent Govt officer (including collector ) can affect life of how many citizens in his/her carrier in decision making?
and so many more.

a incompetent person also can affect students/citizens of reserved category as well.

¶ Respect for all, reward for the worthy, reservation for none.

Agree with above quote completely, nothing more to say…