Ambrane P1000 power bank (10400mAh) first-impressions and teardown
- 15351
- 30
-
- Last Comment
- Sort By
bumblefoot wrote:
well presented. karma.
+1:-} …
Krish Avatar wrote:
bumblefoot wrote:
well presented. karma.
+1:-} …
+15 KG to OP
bumblefoot wrote:
well presented. karma.
well presented, sirji it can be added in blog & OP be given credits
wow nice explanation. good how to give karma?
Wow..Superb bro ..
What a presentation ..
Claps…:-}
And what was the price this power bank you bought from paytm?
jeswinjoy3453 wrote:
Wow..Superb bro ..
What a presentation ..
Claps…:-}
And what was the price this power bank you bought from paytm?
https://paytm.com/shop/p/ambrane-p-1000-portabl...
1349 for the powerbank, 50% cashback. So the effective price was 675Rs. Right now, with 40% cashback, it’s effectively at 810Rs. At the price I got it, it was a no-brainer compared to Xiaomi’s 1k, added to the fact that I needed a power bank now, and Xiaomi’s Power bank is oos since several days now.
Superrbbbb Presentation dude…
You deserve a 500 karmas for it..
@admin/mods Please do the needful..
I have added the Karma from my side..
I have also ordered this with the current 40% off and awaiting delivery..
The AMG (Ahh-h-h-h-h-h My God) Review… One of the best (if not the best) reviews of DD. KG.
Ran into the first performance issue:
Charging Nokia phones with the Nokia pin adapter failed. I’ll post more details with pics soon, but apparently Nokia non-USB chargers charge at 7-8Volts, not 5V as mentioned on the chargers.
Performance Update:
For the device to be charged, I used my month-old Dell Venue 7 tablet which has a 4100mAh battery. I took the charge level readings every 10 minutes with the tablet switched off.
As is obvious from the graph, the tablet charged once completely and 87% the second time, giving an approximate capacity of 7,700 mAh.
The tablet does not charge at a constant current throughout, so the graph isn’t expected to be a straight line, but it’s obvious that the Power Bank’s display doesn’t indicate the charge level correctly as it displayed 66% while it had obviously supplied more than 50% of its capacity at the end of the tablet’s first charge. I wouldn’t rely on the power bank’s display as an accurate measure of its state of charge.
The display starts flashing when it reaches 3% and the power bank automatically shuts itself at 0%, preventing over-discharge
Charging the power bank:
I Charged the power bank with a 2.1A charger just in case it could draw more than 1A, but it charged from 0% to 99% in about 11 hours, indicating that the power bank does limit charging current to 1A.
As opposed to my previous post, it does charge to 100%, but it took nearly an hour to go from 99% to 100%. However, trickle charging this final 1% for this last hour is very important, not doing so gave just 7300mAh, a deficit of over 5% of the capacity.
Thanks for update.
Very good review man…..you deserve a thumbsup (y)
Krish Avatar wrote:
bumblefoot wrote:
well presented. karma.
+1:-} …
+2
Karma for presentation
Please help me which should I buy xiaomi 10k mahbpower bank for 1k or ambrane 10400mah power bank for 675 rs which is of worth , xiaomi is better than ambrane but it lacks 1ampere output to charge phone slow and safe . please reply soon .
goyal.dkg wrote:
Please help me which should I buy xiaomi 10k mahbpower bank for 1k or ambrane 10400mah power bank for 675 rs which is of worth , xiaomi is better than ambrane but it lacks 1ampere output to charge phone slow and safe . please reply soon .
Xiaomi, without question, is much, much better than the Ambrane power bank.
First, about your power concerns:
You could plug your phone into a 1000A 5V source (if one exists) and it would still be safe. The phone only draws as much current as it requires, the charger can NEVER force more current as long as the voltage is constant (Ohms law) at 5V.
HOWEVER, as for value for money, Ambrane on paytm’s sale beats the Xiaomi power bank. You get about 8000mAH usable charge (tested my own power bank) from the Ambrane at Rs. 675 whereas about 9500mAh (Not tested myself, but in line with Xiaomi’s claim of 93% efficiency) from the Xiaomi for Rs. 999
If you have a 2A USB wall charger, the Mi power bank charges twice as fast as the Ambrane. It also has far less potential to fail (better circuit design, components and build). Whereas, with the Ambrane, you get the advantage of being able to charge two devices at once.
Both power banks come without wall chargers. If you only have a 1A wall charger, Xiaomi’s faster charging rate makes no difference. That’s one less pro for you.
well presented.. KG
Hi all,
i have got xiaomi 10400 from Flipkart. I bought that for my LG optimus G E970 and Moto e.
My issue is: Lg optimus G has a charger with output rating 5V and 1A. and Moto e has 5V and 550ma
1) is it ok to use this xiaomi powerbank with output 5V and 2A current to charge these devices designed with low charging current circuit?
2.If yes, as one dimer said the phone can not draw more current, then why do the companies make charger of low output ( 5v 550ma in moto e) where they could have easily gone for 2a charger and charge the device faster. I dont think pricing of 5v 2a charger and 5v 550 ma charger to be too different.
3.Why would they mention the current in the output rating if voltage is fixed at 5V? that means the power ratings are different (p = VI)
Request Knowledgeible dimers to please clarify.. Thx in advance
1.
gyanr wrote:
Hi all,
i have got xiaomi 10400 from Flipkart. I bought that for my LG optimus G E970 and Moto e.
My issue is: Lg optimus G has a charger with output rating 5V and 1A. and Moto e has 5V and 550ma
1) is it ok to use this xiaomi powerbank with output 5V and 2A current to charge these devices designed with low charging current circuit?
2.If yes, as one dimer said the phone can not draw more current, then why do the companies make charger of low output ( 5v 550ma in moto e) where they could have easily gone for 2a charger and charge the device faster. I dont think pricing of 5v 2a charger and 5v 550 ma charger to be too different.
3.Why would they mention the current in the output rating if voltage is fixed at 5V? that means the power ratings are different (p = VI)
Request Knowledgeible dimers to please clarify.. Thx in advance
1) Yes, it’s ok to use power banks with any USB powered device. For example: http://www.sony.co.in/productcategory/sto-batte… (see the last point: Universal usage)
2) Companies don’t include 2A chargers with all products because:
- Chargers of low output cost less. Check out pricing details of 2A vs 1A chargers from any one company to verify this if you want. (Don’t compare the price of a 2A brandless ‘chinese’ charger with Apple’s 1A charger)
- For most phones shipped with 550mA or 1A chargers, the phone can’t charge itself at 2A, so it won’t charge at 4x/ 2x the speed if you plug it into a 2A charger. It might charge your device marginally faster if the phone supports faster charging. Li-Ion cells need to be charged with specific voltage and current characteristics (http://www.ti.com/lit/an/snva533/snva5…df) at specific states of charge (Charge %), so all USB charged Li-Ion powered devices have their own charging regulators built in, which are capable of limiting current and switching off charging if excess voltage is supplied.
3) Of course, the power ratings are different! 2A chargers are 10W (2Ax5V), 1A chargers are 5watts (1Ax5V). These are maximum ratings.
Your question is a commonly asked (and answered) question on Engineering/ electronics forums.
Check out http://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/…
The answer posted there is as follows:
This is a very common question here.Current is pulled depending on the load, not pushed by the charger.
If the load needs or pulls 1A, then the power supply must be able to supply 1A. If it is capable of supplying more, then that’s fine; the load will not pull more just because it’s connected to a supply with greater capacity.
Think of it this way: A mains power outlet can operate a small space heater which may require 1500 watts. But it also can charge your phone. Your phone does not suddenly burn up or consume more power, even though it is plugged into a supply that is obviously capable of much more current.
Or this: http://www.fasttech.com/forums/1207400/t/100154…
Yes, you can. Regardless the current, as long as the charger has 5V voltage and max current higher than 1A, it should be ok. Chargers are voltage sources, (the adapter provides a stable voltage output (5V) and the device (this powerbank) decides how much current to draw (1A)). Your charger’s specification says it provides a maximum of 2Amps. That means it will sustain its 5V output voltage up to a current of 2A.
There’s a far more detailed explanation here, I’m not pasting the whole thing on this thread (too long). If you’re curious, read it (highly recommended)
http://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/…
The points about current are
A constant-voltage supply doesn’t determine the current: the load, which in this case is the device, does. If Johnny wants to eat two apples, he’s only going to eat two whether you put 2, 3, 5, or 20 apples on the table. A device that wants 2 A of current works the same way. It will draw 2 A whether the power supply can only provide the 2 A, or whether it could have supplied 3, 5, or 20 A. The current rating of a supply is what it can deliver, not what it will always force thru the load somehow. In that sense, unlike with voltage, the current rating of a power supply must be at least what the device wants but there is no harm in it being higher. A 9 volt 5 amp supply is a superset of a 9 volt 2 amp supply, for example.
If your device or broken wall wart says 9 V DC, get a 9 V DC replacement. The right voltage and type of voltage are important: a too high voltage may damage your device, a too low voltage too, though that’s less common. But at a too low voltage it may not work properly.Get a power supply at minimum the rated current. If the device says 500 mA, get a power supply that can deliver at least that. A 100 mA wall wart may overheat and set your house on fire if not properly protected. A 1000 mA is safe, even if you only need 500 mA
Very good review…KG
I purchased ambrane 20400 mh power bank but it is running fine and charging all
Nice review for the products
one of the best reviews i have seen..!!
nice
Annamalai Nārāyaṇa wrote:
posting few images of my 20800 mah battery which i got at 1350 INR from paytm.
Excellent pics
KG
Could you post a pic of the other side of the PCB too? And mention the numbers printed on the ICs? I hope that’s not asking too much from someone who has just ripped apart a shiny new gadget
(also, is that a genuine Beats Pill in the first pic? )
Mr_N wrote:Annamalai Nārāyaṇa wrote:
posting few images of my 20800 mah battery which i got at 1350 INR from paytm.
Excellent pics
KG
Could you post a pic of the other side of the PCB too? And mention the numbers printed on the ICs? I hope that’s not asking too much from someone who has just ripped apart a shiny new gadget(also, is that a genuine Beats Pill in the first pic? )
thankyou.
here is the pic
yes the beats is original to the best of my knowledge, my friend who works in Caribbean Cruise-lines bought it for me as a return gift for a help i did last year.
guys any power bank with panasonic Li-ion batteries (18650 size) ?
Ambrane : samsung
Xiaomi : LG
Offtopic:
can i buy one 2400 mAH power bank and can replace it with 3400 mAH cell ? will it cause any problem ?