2024 Election - All Discussion under one roof

Those who deal in cash, won't understand the Pain of Taxes.

Last FY PnL.

See charges.

Leave Brokerage.

If i trade in Intraday/Positional FnO.

(1) There is Brokerage by Broker.

(2) Exchange (BSE/NSE) Transaction Charges.

(3) Security Transaction tax by Govt of India

(4) SEBI Turnover Fees.

(5) Stamp Duty.

(6) NSE protection fund charges or whatever.

( 7)And the Integrated GST again on the above charges.

These charges are applied on the basis of Per order and Fund utilized on per order.

Whatever remains is the profit.

Now comes to Climax.

I have to pay the advance tax on the profit I have after all these charges which are according to the tax slab defined by govt of India.

Almost 20% of profit is being eaten by govt of India after the brokerage, in which GOI has ZERO contribution.

At least these types of Taxes are curses for us.

She is a puppet and FYI her husband is kattar congressi/communist. 

People were saying dictator-dictator modiji be like yeh lo, isse kehte hai dictatorship..

Darkness ahead for working class..

If u r among top 5% indian who earns more than 10L/yr then bad as tax would increase for u, tax slab is kinda fixed, like 10yr ago people earning 10L has 30% tax, but that 10L is like 20L of today, by not increasing tax slab govt playing long game, where due to time and inflation u'll pay more tax automatically

For others it doesn't matter

We needed a more sympathetic leader in finance ministry. In case of Nirmala tai, the letters sym are missing.

Hit me with more taxes already. My body is ready. 

 Main pyaz khata hoon so I don't know bro.

She has done fairly well. India continues to be fastest growing economy despite the numerous challenges such as the COVID, Ukraine and Israel crisis and various other supply chain disruptions. It is quick and simple to criticize someone, but difficult to offer a solution. It’s unfortunate that some people are unable to see the bigger picture. Forget Nirmala Sitharaman, No finance minister, regardless of political party affiliation, can reduce tax rates until the following issues are addressed, as all these factors contribute to tax increases.

1. Overpopulation: Overpopulation leads to slower development, increased demand for food, water, housing, energy, healthcare, transportation, corruption and consequently, Tax rises. Why should tax payers pay for the welfare of people who don't wanna use contraceptives and produce numerous kids. Are jab insaan ho to Cockroaches ki tarah itna bachhe nikaalne ka jaroorat hi kya hai bhai?  Khata khat khata khat itna bachha nikaalte rahenge to bachoon ka future kharaab hoga na. Poverty main rahenge phir bolenge ham to gareeb hai ji, aur welfare schemes mangenge. Where does the money come from? From the tax payer’s pocket.

2. Freebies: Taxes are increased due to political pressure as some political parties & politicians promise free giveaways during elections,launch various “this FREE”,”that FREE”,FREE FREE FREE schemes that are catastrophic for the economy. It has been reiterated by various economists and finance experts. These parties conspire to steal money from the middle / working class and honest tax payers and distribute it to illegal individuals and people who don’t pay any taxes at all but enjoy every welfare scheme. Now, on top of the existing taxes, there are some fools 🤡 suggesting new taxes like "Inheritance Tax" as if previous taxes were not enough. 😡 Where does the money come from? From the tax payer’s pocket.

3. Illegal Rohingya and Bangladeshi aliens: Tax payers are forced to pay more taxes because illegal Rohingya and Bangladeshi immigrants are sucking their hard earned money & unfortunately some political parties are helping these illegal aliens to settle in our country & gulp tax payer’s money. Tax payers find it difficult to buy a good home, invest in stock market, plan for their future, buy a 4 wheeler.😢 Kids of tax payers are unable to get iPhone, PSP, xbox, Gaming laptop, a good bike etc coz Rohingya & Bangladeshi intruders are eating their money.🥹😓  Ye chahte hain ki tax payers tax bharta rahe aur freeloaders ko sabkuch free main milta rahe, aur govt taxpayers ki pocket se paisa nikaalkar in parasites ke saath inka bachhe bhi paalta rahe.😡 Illegal Rohingya Bangladeshi immigrants should be kicked out ASAP. Only legal Indian citizens should be entitled to government welfare programs funded by tax payer's hard earned money. Where does the money come from? From the tax payer’s pocket.

4. Catastrophic schemes like Old Pension Scheme (OPS): Many experts and economists have warned that reverting to old pension scheme will be catastrophic. OPS will worsen inequality and lower economic growth in the states. With OPS, collected tax will be used to give money to those who are now not contributing to the GDP, rather than being utilized for the development of infrastructure. They ought to have saved money during the period when they were getting paid. Saying that they should receive compensation in their retirement years because they worked hard during working years is illogical. Private companies don’t give any pension. If Private sector employees can pay taxes and still plan their retirement, why can’t Govt employees do the same? And consider the issues that may arise 15-20 years down the line when there will be a sizable retiree population due to the government employees’ continuous growth. Just imagine the outflow and catastrophe it will bring. DesiDime, Microsoft, Ola, Google, Apple, Tesla ka bhi employees hai, wo to nahin maang raha pension. Wo jinda nahin rehta kya retirement ke baad? They know how to save, invest and plan their future. It's financial planning that matters. People who want to implement the OPS are doing it simply for political gains, ignoring the future problems. They think that apne baap ka kya jaata hai, kaun sa apne pocket se dena hai. Jayega to tax payers ki pocket se na. 🤬 They know they won't be there in any case when the issues worsen in 15-20 years. The task will be handled by someone else. While the OPS may benefit the govt employees, it will wreak havoc on economy and tax payers. People can easily get more than 50% of their most recent drawn pay as recurring income if they can make sensible contributions to the NPS. If, God forbid, OPS is implemented, where does the money come from? From the tax payer’s pocket.

It's time to wake up! Think about it and raise your voice. After all, it's our hard-earned money. Why should it be taken from us and given to someone else who doesn't even contribute a single penny but enjoys all government benefits. We are not here to carry someone else's burden.

https://theprint.in/opinion/standard-deviation/...

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india...

https://www.desidime.com/discussions/2024-elect...

What's the whole deal about her economist husband criticizing the ruling govt?

Can't expect anything better from PM.

Never hated anyone this much in my life🙂

Looting continues gg....there is no end 😱

I don't like these type of ministers just like strict (khonkhar) masterni for backbenchers.

Ise finance ka f bhi pta hai

Bad days ahead..she was planning to increase ltcg tax, you might have heard also before election, she denied it and but now I think she will implement in next budget...

Also in that bse conference, someone asked why govt should take the benefit as tax if I am taking all the pain and risk... Check her reply

Worst fm in Indian history...bad days ahead for tax payers

If they fire her ..she will expose everyone 🤣

Pahale income tax do, taxable income se fir har chiz ke liye gst do.. what's going on

Even on education, foods also

worst person ever messed up defence big time while at it, finance is in tatters after gst and demon tisation, coutry debt is 200 lac crores, who is going to repay it ? modi or she or bjp ? , taxes are record high

now plan will be to remove ltcg and remove 12% gst slab by pushing all items of 12 to 18% increasing taxes by another 50%

target is in 2014 there were 24 crore hungry left in india, 2022 we are now 85 crore free ration, by 2028 we should be 120 crores on roads and free ration queues

rip economy

Bhai jab itne supporters hai to inko support kyu nahi milta actual me I am totally confused.

In next 100 days she will continue and there will be change after that..

In short KT degi kisi ko (knowledge transfer)

Painful years ahead for all normal good Indian citizens due to voting or whatever in reality bringing back this useless Government 🤦‍♂️

https://www.instagram.com/reel/C8EIetcxKGW/?igs...

iF NO NIRMALA THEN WHO ?

People who doesn't know about macroeconomics are crying here about Ms. Sitharaman being Finance Minister. Just compare the Macroeconomic fundamentals of India after 2008 GFC & 2020 Covid, people would get to know the brilliant job she has done.

Dear Admin you must include 49-O in the poll too because none of them are competent and honest enough

We are now closing this thread. Other forum rules remains as it is.